"Lover Song"--covered by Four Year Strong
“Love Song” was released in 2007 as Sara Bareilles first single off her album Little Voice. The song spent forty-one weeks on the Billboard Hot 100. In 2009 the pop-punk band Four Year strong covered the song for the compilation album Punk Goes Pop 2. Both songs share the same lyrics and melody, but sound very different.
The first thing the listener may notice is the speed. Four Year Strong’s version of the song is much faster than the original. This is because Four Year Strong is a high-energy pop-punk band with beats per minute (BPM) typically between 175 and 225 and they changed the original song to fit their style of play. Sara Bareilles’ original song teeters around 100-120 BPM, this difference in speed gives both songs their own personality from the very first note. If Four Year Strong’s cover was the same BPM as the original, it would make their cover of the song seem like a band playing a song verbatim, rather than interpreting it how they see fit.
Another factor the listener may notice is the intensity of both songs. As a whole the original is much softer than the cover. Once again this is due to the style of music each artist plays. I’m sure Sara Bareilles could have made her song just as loud as Four Year Strong’s, but would it work? Sara Bareilles is a singer/songwriter type musician and the arrangements focuses mainly on the lyrics and her piano parts, which are not typically played at the same intensity as guitars and drums in pop-punk.
The organization of the two pieces is almost identical. Besides four measures of piano in the beginning of the original as an introduction, both songs follow this structure:
-Verse
-Pre-Chorus
-Chorus
-Interlude
-Verse
-Pre-Chorus
-Chorus
-Bridge
-Chorus (refrained)
-Outro
The factor that really sets these two songs apart is the timbre each artist conveys. The original is a light-hearted and poppy. The cover still remains that light-hearted feel, however is a driving hard-rock song. The timbre of the drums in the original and the cover are very clean and crisp, but the style of the different drummers makes the drum parts sound different to the listener. The instrumentation used in the two pieces also changes the timbre of the songs. While the original is carried by the piano part, the cover is carried by electric guitar. There is electric guitar in the original however; the tone is light and crisp, while the guitars in the cover are heavy and distorted. The piano used in the cover is a similar tone to the piano in the original but the cover only uses piano as an accent in particular sections.
In conclusion I like the original version of the song better. The cover is the style of music I typically would choose over a pop hit but the feeling and emotion in the original really pull me in. Another reason I like the original version better is because I had high expectations for Four Year Strong to blow this song out of the water when I heard they were doing a cover, but I felt their cover was to typical. Overall I enjoy both of the versions a lot as the lyrics are all about sticking it to the music industry and doing what you feel.